You did not get any from me, but I have some ideas:

* Your reflection is not so good. The logo should gradually Disappear, yours is just flipped and set to a lower opacity.

* Bevel does not look good on light fonts and skinny lines.

* One can tell you just took the transparent gif from the forum and enlarged it cause the image is blurry.
The logo is fairly simple. If it were me who created it, I would have drawn everything from scratch.

np.

yes, a lot of bad logos do get uploaded. I'm not proud of some of my work back when I started making logos here. even some of the new ones I made are not so great.
also I do not see the point of uploading logos with a white / black / colored background

I even had someone go through all my logos (when there were around 50-60 of them) and cast a negative vote on each one of them (never found out who did this or the reason why and to be honest: I don't really care)

fact is: there is a certain standard on this site and what people expect to see.
sometimes they like your work, sometimes they don't.

go through some of the tutorials, that may help. also check your logos against a black and a white background.
just don't let the negative votes bring you down ;)